Western Omelet Frittata

This Western Omelet Frittata is packed with bell peppers, red onion, ham, and cheese for an easy, healthy, and high-protein breakfast. It's absolutely delicious!

This western frittata takes all the flavors of this classic diner omelet and combines them in a simple baked frittata. It's great for meal prep, delicious warm or room temperature, and works for breakfast, lunch, or dinner.

I have always been a sucker for a good Western omelet, especially on brunch dates! I love the combination of red onions, bell peppers, ham, and cheese. However, I don't love the calorie count. Many restaurant omelets have between 500-750 calories and between 30-40 grams of fat! As much as I crave this omelet, I couldn't justify using a good chunk of my calories on one dish.

Luckily, it's easy to make a healthier version at home that tastes just as good. Since omelets can be a bit tricky, I like to make a frittata instead. Plus, it keeps better in the fridge if there are leftovers!

Whether you call this an omelet, frittata, or just an egg recipe, you are going to love it! Enjoy it for breakfast, or brunch, or even save it for your lunch later in the week. Egg lovers will also want to try these recipes: Broccoli and Cheese Frittata, Sweet Potato and Spinach Egg Muffins, and Asparagus Feta Frittata.

What You’ll Need and Easy Swaps

All of the ingredients are whole and fresh and add incredible flavor to this egg recipe. Here's what I used in my frittata.

• Eggs: I used the entire egg for this frittata. If you are trying to replace egg yolks with egg whites, the rule to remember is that it takes 2 egg whites to equal 1 egg.
• Milk: Use skim milk. If you are lactose intolerant, you can use your favorite type of non-dairy milk. Just make sure it is unsweetened.
• Olive Oil: You only need enough olive oil to coat the bottom of your skillet so you can cook the vegetables. You can replace olive oil with avocado oil or ghee.
• Onion: Dice the onion really small, unless you enjoy the taste of onion slices. I used red onion, but you can use white or yellow instead.
• Bell Peppers: Any type of peppers will taste delicious in this omelet! I used red and green bell peppers, diced up really small. You can use yellow bell peppers or add some jalapenos or serranos for a little spice.
• Ham: To cut back on fat and calories, use lean ham. I like to dice up ham steaks or lean lunch meat. You could also swap in turkey bacon, sausage, or deli turkey but then it won’t be a true western omelet.
• Garlic: Mince a garlic clove fresh for the best flavor. In a pinch, you can use garlic powder instead. This isn’t traditional but I love the extra flavor it adds.
• Shredded Cheese: Use reduced-fat cheese or full fat - whatever you prefer. Cheddar cheese is typically used in a Western omelet, but you can have fun and use any other type of cheese. Pepper jack will add some spice, mozzarella will add a creamier texture, goat cheese or feta cheese gives you some more bite.

What To Serve With A Western Omelette

What you serve with it depends on when you are eating it. Since this has so much protein in it, I like to enjoy a bowl of sliced fruit on the side. This banana berry smoothie has lots of fruity flavors and protein in it too. For extra fiber, enjoy an English muffin with some butter!

If you are making this for your breakfast, then make some Greek yogurt and flax pancakes with it. They are full of gut-healthy fiber and nutrients.

Or, these baked blueberry banana squares are perfect any time of day. They add a bit of sweetness to the savory omelet.

If you are serving this omelet for lunch or dinner, pair it with this tasty Spinach Salad or a bowl of spicy tomato soup.

Recipe Tips And Ideas For The Western Frittata

Follow these tips to make sure that this frittata turns out perfectly every single time!

• Pan-fry the vegetables before you use them in the omelet. This will soften them, so they aren't too crispy in the soft eggs. Try different veggies like in this Vegetable Frittata.
• Pre-cook the omelet in the frying pan. This helps the edges and middle firm up and prevents it from burning in the broiler.
• Use a cast-iron skillet! This way, you will be able to do all the pan-frying and move it to the broiler without trying to figure out how to transfer it to an oven-safe dish.
• Turn leftovers into the most delicious Breakfast Tacos.

Frequently Asked Questions

Here are some questions I frequently get asked about by some readers…

Can I add tomatoes to it?

Yes, tomatoes will taste delicious in this omelet frittata. Either slice them really thin and add them to the egg mixture or chop up some cherry or grape tomatoes and mix them in. Both options are perfect ways to add tomatoes!

What are some healthy condiments to add to frittatas?

This frittata has so much flavor that you might want to use a lighter-tasting condiment. Sugar-free ketchup, salsa, or even some hot sauce or all great low-calorie options.

What is the difference between an omelet and a frittata?

The main difference between them is how you cook them. Frittatas are slowly cooked over low heat, while omelets are cooked quickly over high heat. In my recipe, I did a combination of both! I cooked it really quickly on the stove and then placed it under the broiler.

How do you store leftover frittata?

The best way to store leftover frittata is in an airtight food storage container. Keep it in the refrigerator for up to 3 days.

How do you make this dairy-free?

It's really easy to make this frittata dairy-free. Just use your favorite dairy-free milk replacement instead of skim milk. I like unsweetened almond milk the best. Then, replace the cheese with your preferred dairy-free cheese. It will still taste delicious!

More Delicious Egg Recipes You’ll Love:

• Southwest Black Bean Egg Muffins
• Broccoli And Cheese Frittata
• Healthy Freezer Breakfast Burritos
• Quiche Cupcakes
• Baked Frittata With Tomato And Goat Cheese