Blackened Chicken Salad

This healthy Blackened Chicken Salad will quickly become your go-to salad to stuff in sandwiches and lettuce wraps. It's creamy, spicy, and has a hint of sweetness and is a lunchtime staple along with this buffalo chicken salad and cranberry almond chicken salad.

Classic chicken salad will always have a place in my heart but sometimes it's fun to mix things up. This Blackened Chicken Salad does just that.

Using a homemade cajun seasoning made with ingredients you have at home in your spice cabinet, you can take the creamy salad in a completely different direction. Paired with crunchy carrots and green onions, it's such a yummy twist on chicken salad and tastes amazing tucked into sandwich bread or wrapped up in lettuce.

For anyone wondering, this is also a copycat of the Whole Foods Blackened Chicken Salad. It's one of my favorite things from their deli case but at $13.99 pound, it's much more economical to make it at home. To make things quick and easy, I usually start with leftover cooked chicken or rotisserie chicken.

Then for the dressing, I like to use a combination of Greek yogurt and sour cream. Using sour cream adds a richness I love and I almost always use sour cream in my chicken and tuna salad recipes. To that, I add lemon juice for brightness and a touch of honey for sweetness. It balances out the spices. 

Now let's talk about the spices. I like to make mine from scratch so I have control over the proportions in the blackening seasoning, but a store-bought Cajun or blackening season would work just as well.

For my blackening seasoning, I like to use paprika, garlic powder, onion powder, oregano, black pepper, and cayenne. If cayenne is too spicy for you, you could use chili powder instead. It has a milder flavor and is less spicy. 

More Ideas You'll Love

More Chicken Salad Ideas

Looking for more creative recipes for chicken salad? This quick and nutritious meal is great for lunch, dinner, and a high-protein snack. More Chicken Salad Recipes

Low carb? If you want a low carb or keto version of this salad, you can make a few easy changes. Leave out the honey to start. Then replace the yogurt with either full-fat yogurt or mayo. Do the same for the sour cream, opting for full-fat sour cream. Then use half the amount of carrots and add some celery for crunch.

Vegetarian? Instead of the chicken, you can use a vegetarian chicken product like this one or just use chickpeas. To keep a salad like consistency, mash about half of the chickpeas gently with a fork before mixing them into the salad.

Ways to Serve this Blackened Chicken Salad

• Sandwich: There is a reason chicken salad sandwiches have stayed popular for years. With this spicy chicken salad, I like to use sourdough bread that's slightly toasted and add lettuce or sprouts.  
• Salad: Served on a big bed of greens with plenty of fresh veggies. Add tomatoes, cucumbers, celery, and apples for a really delicious combination.
• Low Carb Wrap: For a low carb sandwich option, use a low carb wrap or tortilla. My favorite options are Flatout Light Wraps, Ole Tortillas, and La Tortilla Factory Tortillas. 
• Crackers and raw veggies: Sometimes I like to have this salad as a snack or a snack style lunch. Paired with some crunchy crackers and sliced raw veggies, it's a perfect appetizer, snack, or lunch.
• Tomato cups: For a fun presentation, you can carefully hollow out tomatoes and serve this chicken salad inside the hollowed out tomatoes. It's also a lower carb way to enjoy it.
• Cucumber boats: Similar to the tomatoes, you can also scoop out the inside of a cucumber using a spoon and fill it with the tuna salad. It adds a nice crunch to the dish and is a really fun way to serve it.